Background Check for Tenants: What Landlords Need to Know
One in four background checks reveal criminal history. Most small landlords skip background checks entirely or run them and don't know how to interpret the results. This is risky. A background check can reveal eviction history, criminal activity, and rental violations that would never show up on an application. Here's everything you need to know about tenant background checks.
Why Background Checks Matter
Liability. If you know someone has a criminal history and you rent to them, and they commit a crime on your property, you're liable. Knowing and not acting = negligent. Pattern identification. Background checks reveal patterns: multiple evictions, drug charges, outstanding warrants. Rental violations. Even without criminal history, checks reveal rental-specific problems: prior evictions, civil judgments for property damage, collections on rental accounts. Peace of mind. You know who you're renting to. Background checks cost $30-$50 per applicant. One bad decision costs $5,000-$20,000. Background checks cost $30-$50 per applicant. The cost is worth it.
What Background Checks Reveal
A comprehensive tenant background check shows: Criminal history: Arrests (even if charges dropped), Convictions (felonies and misdemeanors), Pending charges, Outstanding warrants, Sex offender registry status. Eviction history: Previous evictions, Unlawful detainers (legal term for evictions), Civil judgments related to rental disputes. Financial history: Collections accounts, Bankruptcy filings, Civil judgments (property damage, unpaid rent). Identity verification: Name verification, Social Security number verification, Address history. Rental violations: Small claims judgments, Broken lease records, Unpaid utilities in rental units.
Evaluating Criminal History: The Right Way
Criminal history exists. But not all criminal history is equal. Felony vs. misdemeanor: Felony = serious crime (usually jail time > 1 year), Misdemeanor = lesser crime (usually jail time < 1 year). Violent vs. property crime: Violent crime = assault, robbery, domestic violence. Property crime = theft, burglary, arson. Drug offense = possession, trafficking, manufacturing. Timeframe: Recent conviction (within 1-2 years) = high risk. Older conviction (5+ years) = lower risk, especially if no additional arrests. Pattern vs. single incident: Single incident = may be mistake or youthful error. Multiple arrests/convictions = pattern of behavior. Rehabilitation: Has the person been employed since conviction? Stable address? No new arrests? Education or training since conviction? How to make decisions: 1) Run the check, 2) Evaluate context (timeframe, type, pattern), 3) Interview tenant ("I see a conviction in 2015. Can you tell me about that?"), 4) Let them explain, 5) Make fair decision based on context, 6) Document your reasoning (legal protection). Legal note: You can consider criminal history, but you must do so fairly. Blanket bans (reject all felons) may be discriminatory. Evaluate case-by-case and document.
Eviction History: The Big Red Flag
Even one eviction signals risk. Multiple evictions signal a pattern. What eviction means: Tenant went to court over rental obligations, Landlord documented the problem officially, Court ruled against the tenant, This is a matter of public record. Evaluating eviction: How many evictions? (1 = concerning; 2+ = pattern), Why was tenant evicted? (Non-payment vs. property damage vs. lease violation), How long ago? (Recent = higher risk; 5+ years = lower risk), What happened after? (Stable housing history since?). How to respond: Interview the tenant: "I see an eviction in 2018. What happened?" Listen to their story. Sometimes there's context: Lost job (but employed for 3 years since), Landlord dispute (but clean record since), Mistake (but learned, improved). Recent evictions are riskier than old ones. Multiple evictions show a pattern. Trust your judgment. If someone has multiple recent evictions, they're high risk.
Rental Violations & Collections
These are warning signs separate from criminal history. Collections on rental accounts: Bill sent to collection agency for non-payment, Shows they defaulted on rental financial obligations, Direct predictor of rental payment problems. Small claims judgments: Landlord sued for property damage, Court ruled in favor of landlord, Tenant owes damages, Shows they damage property. Broken leases: Tenant broke lease early, left without proper notice, Shows they don't honor agreements. Unpaid utilities in rental units: Electric, gas, water bills left unpaid, Shows neglect of rental responsibilities. How to evaluate: Single violation = may be error or specific circumstance, Multiple violations = pattern of rental irresponsibility. If applicant has multiple rental violations, they're high risk.
Fair Housing Considerations
Landlord liability exists here. Evaluate backgrounds fairly. Do: Apply same screening criteria to all applicants, Evaluate criminal history case-by-case, Document your reasoning for rejection, Give applicants chance to explain, Consider context and timeframe. Don't: Reject all applicants with criminal history (discriminatory), Assume worst about certain demographics, Reject based on protected classes (race, national origin, disability, etc.), Reject without documenting why. Legal protection: Save all background reports (3+ years), Document your decision and reasoning, Apply same criteria to all applicants, Be consistent across all properties.
Your Background Check Process
1. Run background check on all applicants (no exceptions) 2. Review report for red flags 3. Interview tenant about red flags 4. Evaluate context and fairness 5. Make approval or rejection decision 6. Document decision and reasoning 7. Save all records Background checks cost $30-$50. One bad decision costs $5,000-$20,000.
Want more landlord insights?
Sign up for our newsletter! We share screening strategies, fair housing guidelines, and tenant evaluation techniques. Join Des Moines landlords building profitable, compliant rental businesses.
